Back to blog

Claude vs ChatGPT: How to Adapt Your Prompts for Each Model

Understanding the differences between Claude and ChatGPT can dramatically improve your results. Here's what you need to know.

While both Claude and ChatGPT are powerful language models, they have distinct characteristics that require different prompting approaches. Understanding these differences can significantly improve your results.

Key Differences in Model Behavior

Response Style

ChatGPT tends to be more conversational and creative, often providing detailed explanations even when not explicitly requested.

Claude is typically more concise and focused, sticking closely to what was asked without extra elaboration unless prompted.

Handling Ambiguity

ChatGPT often makes assumptions when faced with ambiguous prompts and proceeds with a best guess.

Claude is more likely to ask clarifying questions or explicitly state assumptions it's making.

Prompting Strategies for ChatGPT

Leverage Its Creativity

ChatGPT excels at creative tasks. Use prompts like:

• "Brainstorm 10 unique features for..."
• "Generate creative alternatives to..."
• "Come up with an innovative approach for..."

Control Verbosity

If you want concise responses from ChatGPT, be explicit:

• "Give me a brief, one-paragraph explanation"
• "List only the key points without elaboration"
• "Provide a concise answer in 3 sentences or less"

Prompting Strategies for Claude

Request Elaboration

Claude often needs encouragement to provide detailed explanations:

• "Explain in detail..."
• "Walk me through each step..."
• "Provide comprehensive analysis with examples..."

Provide Clear Structure

Claude responds well to structured prompts with clear sections:

"Please provide:

1. A summary of the problem
2. Three possible solutions
3. Pros and cons for each
4. Your recommended approach"

Code Generation: Different Approaches

ChatGPT Code Prompts

ChatGPT often benefits from examples and iterative refinement:

• Start with a basic request
• Review the output
• Ask for specific improvements

Claude Code Prompts

Claude works better with comprehensive, upfront specifications:

• Include all requirements in the initial prompt
• Specify edge cases and error handling
• Define the complete interface first

Handling Complex Reasoning

For ChatGPT: Use chain-of-thought prompting: "Let's solve this step by step"

For Claude: Provide a clear framework: "Analyze this using the following criteria: 1) ... 2) ... 3) ..."

Document Analysis

ChatGPT: Better for creative interpretation and finding patterns

Claude: Superior for precise extraction and literal interpretation

Best Practices for Both

1. Be Specific: Both models benefit from clear, specific instructions
2. Provide Context: Background information helps both models
3. Use Examples: Both respond well to concrete examples
4. Iterate: Don't expect perfection on the first try

When to Use Which Model

Use ChatGPT for:

• Creative writing and brainstorming
• Conversational interactions
• Tasks requiring extensive elaboration

Use Claude for:

• Precise analysis and data extraction
• Tasks requiring careful adherence to instructions
• Situations where you want measured, thoughtful responses

Conclusion

Understanding these differences allows you to choose the right model for each task and craft prompts that play to each model's strengths. Experiment with both and develop a feel for when each excels.